Lee

I was watching a report on which video games parents should avoid buying their children for the Holiday season due to graphic violence. I think that is an important consumer/parent topic to address.

There are certainly some games that absolutely unnerve me in their violence. I have seen the commericial for the game centered around the Vietnam War. It is more disturbing that the game makers decided to pump in anti-war songs from that era over the glorification of violence without getting the irony of what they are doing.

That said, the real topic I wish to explore in relation to the report I saw is how the parents and reporters featured in the report quickly moved from helpful guides in gift buying to the subject of outright banning these games.

Do you believe these games should be banned?

Personally, I don't. I don't like these games, but I believe they have to right to sell them.....to adults, that is.

That is where I feel the parents and the reporters have strayed from the truth of the matter. Legally, no minor can buy these games anymore than they can purchase or view a rated "R" film. I believe the laws are already in place and it is now the parents that need to step up to their responsibility. Don't buy kids these games. Parents don't even need a sensualized report for guidance. On each box, a rating system is stamped on all games. If the game is a rated "M" game, it will quite clearly state that this game should only be played by adults. Retailers face serious fines if they sell these games to minors.

I realize there are still ways minors can get a hold of these games: through friends whose parents aren't as responsible, through online retailers such as ebay or amazon.com, and through a parent's poorly guarded library. I just feel that some parents need to stop pointing the finger elsewhere while demanding a ban on a product and, instead, take a more active role in being aware of what their children are playing and purchasing.

What are your thoughts on the topic?

__________________
Some call me a genius. Others are not the sarcastic type.

aftermath

I would have to agree with you Mac. Since the days of Mortal Kombat, video games have had ratings. And with current laws, which I don't know if they are in Canada or not, childern can't get their hands on these games without some form of adult help.

I have been playing mature rated games since mortal kombat, and I find the ability to take my anger out in a game instead of doing anything about it in real life very nice. But there are those that take it too far.

I thought it funny that they include drugs, sex, crude humor, in the ratings. But the ratings are very good. I was at the game shop and a women was buying games and they told her right there that one of the games was mature and wasn't suitable for children.

So, I would have to say that the parents should watch what they are buying their children. But I also think the age to buy mature rated games should be lowered to 16 or 17. At that age, most people can tell teh difference between reality and the game.

__________________
go visit...
To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

Foxbat

I agree that parents should take more responsibility for what their kids do and play.

I am not in favour of a ban as such but I do believe that violence itself will not sell a game(although it may initially). But if the game is utter garbage, that point will soon become apparent and sales will plummet. The company involved in making such nonsense will suffer finacial loss as to its unwise investment. This, I believe, is the best censorship of all.

I cite as an example of trash - Hooligans: Storm Over Europe.....where is it now?

__________________
Vini Vidi Evasi

Leto

IIRC, the ratings are standards done by the video games industry so yes they're internationals. Every country enforces them differently.

Rane Longfox

Completely the parent's responsibility. If you buy your kid an 18-rated game, like Getaway or GTA, you have exactly no legs to stand on when you complain about it being too violent.

You can't even get a job in a video game shop that sells 18-rated games over here untill you're 18 yourself, and very few shops will sell to underage customers.

__________________

O xein angellein Lakedaimoniois hoti tede, keimentha tois keinon rhemasi peithomenoi.

AmonRa

well as im a 16 year old my view might be abit biased towards accepting gore in games, but i have to disagree with you.

in my opinion the ratings given to us on the package of a game, or on the cover of a DVD should only be guide lines. the parent will know the child much better than the company that makes these ratings, that is why i think it should be the adult who decides whether or not the game is too gory for their child. i also think that people now adays are alot more stronger towards gore and horror (for example, 60 years ago a man walking round in a costume which is supposed to resemble some sort of slug from mars in a black and white movie was alot more scary than the sort of stuff we have today).

ontop of that every one knows that what we see on the screen is not real blood, just a few hundred red pixels to make the illusion of blood, so i can honsestly say i find it hard how any one can be 'grossed out' by gore in a game.

i'd also like to add that i dont think that blood shed on its own can sell a game, there are many aspects that go into the creation of a game, for example, how it plays, graphics, the 'weapons' (if there are any) , and sound effects etc.etc.

__________________
Klaatu Barada Nikto - just to show i have some SFF knowledge ;)

Leto

100% agreed.

The problem is not being grossed out, but being so accustomed to it, you don't make the difference between this and real life. It's not usually happening on normal kids or teens, but if you already have a kind of mental disorder, it certainly won't help. But as always, attention and guidance from the parents in front of computer and in everyday life should be enough to take care of this. Unless the kid is already a psychopath. It's exactly the same debate for violence on TV, or 60 years ago in pulps.

Once again 100 % agreed.

Hellsheep

I really don't like the last part of this sentence. I haven't seen anyone, who wouldn't understand that particular difference, in my entire life, although that's not very long yet.

I do not belive that there is a problem about being accustomed to violence, as far as you know that killing people is not a nice way to solve problems. And you would get used to it anyway, just watch the news.

"TV doesn't create psychos, TV makes psychos more creative." -Scream
And that also applies to PC-games, you won't murder just because you play brutal games, you'll only do so if you decide to.

Leto

Read again my post before flaming it.
Normal people won't have problem with violence. People with psychological problems will. People with antisocial disorder for exemple (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sociopath) won't make the difference between a socially accepted killing in a game, a TV show or a book and a socially offensive one (getting rid of your neighbour because he's noisy for example).

If video games (specially developed ones) is used in psychiatry, you can suppose it's because this media have an influence on the mind

aftermath

The problem with these violent games is that when you are running through a street and mowing down more than 50 people with my ak-47 and desert eagle, you become accostumed to it. So after playing games like that, what is the death of one person that you watch on a new report?

Now imagine if you had a mental problem? It would become increasingly difficult to seperate the game from reality. And what makes games worse than movies is that you are guiding the violence. You push the button that kills all those pixelated people.

__________________
go visit...
To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

Neon

I think it is entirely on the parent to take an active role in their child's life to show them right and wrong. While some problems stem from inherent gene disorders, I feel most behavior is learned and taught from our environment. I think most children, such as myself, can easily grow up to enjoy games for what they are (entertainment) while still maintain the respect for humanity and understand that killing is wrong. In addition, one could easily go crazy and post a ban on any type of "violence." I suppose we could no longer read most types of fantasy and fiction books, nor study world history (due to wars). For the most part, I feel many people try to displace blame onto these forms of entertainment as opposed to putting the fault onto themselves.

__________________
"Many have made a trade of delusions and false miracles, deceiving the stupid multitude."
---Leonardo Da Vinci

Lee

Leto, I don't think Hellsheep meant to flame you. It sounded to me like he was merely disagreeing with you.

It is good that there is no flaming in the gaming forum because, due to our Super Mario Bros twisted brains, we would insist on flattening each other like side-walking giant mushrooms with fangs.

__________________
Some call me a genius. Others are not the sarcastic type.

scalem X

I don't know how it is in other countries, but in Belgium we do have guidelines for shop owners, but...
Well I'm 17, if I want to buy pornography, I can(as long as the stores are open), if I want to buy strong alcoholic beverages, I can(24/24), If I want to buy violent games I can(as long as the stores are open). (and the same for people of 15 years old and higher).
Do you see extreme violence in Belgium? No, my 10 year old nephew plays GTA vice city, he won't be a killer when he grows up.
it's a matter of policy of the government and the parents I guess, but I don't think you should pay too much attention.
When I learned to read, I freaked out because of a drawing in a book.
(if you type 'demon' and perform a google search you can find thousands)
The same way as some of the first people will have been schocked by some invented stories.
Look to be honest I don't really care and if I ever get kids I will decide some things for them, but I know that they will eventually find their own ways to their needs. And if they are able to get it, they are smart enough to play/watch/drink it.

__________________
I want to take over the world; please help.

'If you want to live; jump into my mouth.'
-the pelican in 'Finding Nemo'

Rane Longfox

Hell, we should ban everything that even hints at violence

not flaming... butactually a fair point, I think. Why complain about games like GTA, when there are hundreds of books out there about serial killers that no-one bats an eyelid at. Have you read Ben Elton's "Past Mortem"? Truly disturbing, graphically portraying a murderer executing his victims while they are still concious in many and varied, but undeniably cruel ways. And it's on the best-sellers list at the moment, I think. Someone with an "antisocial disorder" could pick this up easily, and have a much clearer idea of what they should do to people who (in this case) bullied them at school. Surely this is much worse than a game where you shoot random people. The game is nowhere near as graphic...

I'm not saying that that kind of book should be banned, far from it, but more people read books than play video games, and yet its the video games that draw all the attention. Is this wise?

__________________

O xein angellein Lakedaimoniois hoti tede, keimentha tois keinon rhemasi peithomenoi.

Leto

I didn't say thos games or books should be banned. Hey, I need to eat and testing them is one of my way to get money. Simply, at the start of the discussion we were talking about PEGI indications and parental guidance.
I'm just defending the fact that's a good thing there's guidance rating on game boxes. Some images can be disturbing for some personnalities, and parents may discuss with their kids before buying them games (books and so on) or let them have it. Now, as scalemx said, if the kid is clever enough to escape all controls, he should be clever enough to understand the difference between the game and real life.

However on the stat between readers and videogame players, I wouldn't bet on books as the most popular leisure. But that's a whole new discussion.